
Trusts Need to Stand Up to IRS Scrutiny- Trusts are a familiar part of estate planning, particularly for families transferring substantial wealth. They can provide control over when beneficiaries receive assets, preserve property for future generations and, in some circumstances, reduce the tax consequences of transferring appreciating assets.
However, creating a sophisticated trust is only part of the job. The way assets are transferred, substituted, valued and distributed can determine whether the intended tax treatment survives an IRS challenge.
A current case involving a Nashville family illustrates just how much can be at stake.
In 2018, a Nashville couple established three grantor-retained annuity trusts, commonly called GRATs, for their three children. The two-year irrevocable trusts were funded with marketable securities and interests in closely held businesses and partnerships.
The basic strategy behind a GRAT is relatively straightforward. The grantor retains the right to receive fixed annuity payments during the trust term. If the trust assets grow faster than the IRS's applicable hurdle rate, the excess appreciation can pass to the beneficiaries with potentially little or no gift tax.
In the Elcan family's case, two trusts reportedly generated about $200 million in tax-free wealth for the children.
The dispute arose from how the family handled the annuity payments.
The trust agreements gave the grantor the power to substitute personal property for assets held by the trusts, provided the exchanged property was of equivalent value.
According to court filings, the trusts removed investments and replaced them with promissory notes. Those notes were essentially IOUs promising repayment to the trusts, with interest.
The trusts then used the notes to satisfy their required annuity payments.
The IRS challenged that arrangement, arguing that the use of personal promissory notes to satisfy the annuity obligations did not comply with the rules governing qualified annuity interests.
The agency is seeking more than $736 million, consisting of roughly $614 million in alleged gift taxes and $122 million in penalties.
Trusts Need to Stand Up to IRS Scrutiny
The IRS argues that the case goes beyond whether the family technically exchanged assets of equal value.
The agency contends that putting personal IOUs into the trusts and then effectively using those IOUs to satisfy the grantor's payment obligations amounted to an indirect transaction designed to get around the rules. In its view, the arrangement violated Section 2702 and related Treasury regulations.
If the IRS ultimately prevails, the consequences could be substantial. The agency argues that the IRS could treat the entire $687.5 million initially transferred to the GRATs as a taxable gift.
The taxpayers disagree. They argue that the promissory notes were already assets of the trusts and were legally returned to the grantor to satisfy existing payment obligations.
The Tax Court has not yet ruled on the taxpayers' motion for summary judgment.
The controversy is easier to understand by looking at how a GRAT works.
When someone establishes a GRAT, they transfer assets into an irrevocable trust but retain an annuity interest for a specified period.
The IRS uses a monthly interest rate, known as the Section 7520 rate or hurdle rate, to calculate the value of the retained annuity.
If the assets outperform that rate, the additional appreciation can generally pass to beneficiaries at the end of the trust term without being treated as a taxable gift, assuming the arrangement satisfies the applicable requirements.
If the assets fail to appreciate sufficiently, however, beneficiaries may receive little or nothing after the required annuity payments. The grantor may simply receive much of the transferred property back through those payments.
That makes the structure highly dependent on both the trust terms and the transactions carried out during the trust's life.
The Elcan case does not mean that GRATs or other irrevocable trusts are inherently problematic. It demonstrates something more practical: sophisticated estate planning strategies require careful administration after the documents are signed.
A trust that works exactly as intended on paper can become more complicated when assets are sold, substituted, distributed, or exchanged.
For that reason, consider major transactions involving an irrevocable trust considering the trust agreement and the tax rules that govern it. A transaction that appears economically equivalent to another transaction may not necessarily receive the same tax treatment.
Families sometimes focus heavily on choosing the right trust structure and overlook what happens afterward.
That can be a mistake with high-value trusts. Trustees and beneficiaries may eventually need to handle investment changes, business interests, distributions, substitutions, loans, valuations and other transactions that weren't front and center when the trust was created.
Periodic review can help identify whether the trust still aligns with its original purpose and applicable tax requirements.
Trusts Need to Stand Up to IRS Scrutiny
The pending Elcan case will ultimately provide another data point for families using GRATs and other sophisticated wealth-transfer strategies. More broadly, it shows why estate planning should account for a trust's practical administration, not just the language used to create it.
When significant assets are involved, getting a transaction wrong can cost far more than reviewing it beforehand.
A trust should, therefore, be treated as an ongoing part of an estate plan. As assets and circumstances change, reviewing the trust's provisions and proposed transactions can help ensure that the strategy remains consistent with the family's objectives and the governing rules.
Schedule your phone consultation: THE LAW OFFICES OF CLAUDE S. SMITH, III
Trusts Need to Stand Up to IRS Scrutiny
Reference: Kiplinger (September 26, 2026) "IRS Is Taking a Closer Look at Trusts: What It Means for Estate Planning"
Legal problems are extremely stressful, especially when your family, your health, or your freedom are at stake. At this point in time, you may not even be sure what kinds of questions you need to ask a lawyer, but that’s entirely normal. Whether your situation involves family law, estate planning, elder law, a criminal charge, or a personal injury, we will start by giving you all the information you need.
The way we see it, you deserve to get this information directly from an expert. That’s why we make it easy for you to get in touch with your lawyer, and we never ask you to sit down with a paralegal or assistant instead.
As our relationship continues, we will keep you updated about the status of your case every step of the way. Your lawyer will reach out regularly to tell you about any new developments, and he will also be happy to answer any questions you have throughout the process.
